The sole reason I purchased this mascara was to use it for my bottom lashes. I wasn’t expecting much, just something small that I can use. I chose the waterproof version because waterproof mascaras usually flake less than their washable counterparts. This mascara is fine and dandy, but there was one big problem. The formula was dry as heck, fresh out of the tube. I would have thought that someone left the mascara uncapped for one week or something. I have a Youtube video up where I swipe the brush on my arm. There was barely any product. You can barely see it on my lashes, but on the bright side… it doesn’t clump I’m going to try exchanging this for the washable version and see how the formula is. edit* The nonwaterproof version is a bit more wet. I’m going to play around with it some more.